The colonial era burial grounds and gravemarkers of the upper mid-Atlantic states (Map 1) have been the focus of little research to date. That which has been conducted primarily concerns the New York / New Jersey gravestone carving tradition, originally established in the British communities circa 1720, and its skillfully crafted sandstone markers. Although slate gravestones were imported from New England prior to this time, the vast majority of the earliest markers were simple, unadorned fieldstones. This study examines the fieldstone traditions of colonial New York, New Jersey, and Delaware; more specifically, those markers erected by and for the descendants of the New Netherland colonists. Researchers have claimed that other than the possible uninscribed fieldstone, the early Dutch, who in 1624 first colonized the region, did not use gravemarkers until introduced by the English following the 1664 annexation of New Netherland.  The reasoning behind such claims center on the fact that surviving markers from the New Netherland period have never been identified or documented. Moreover, extant Dutch language gravemarkers appear decades later than the English in the archaeological record of the American northeast. However, evidence suggests that centuries-old marker traditions were in use before English-inspired headstones were adopted. Unfortunately, most of the earliest markers have been lost over the centuries to development pressures, neglect, and misidentification. Because of this, the final resting places of many of America’s first colonists have been, and risk continuing to be, disturbed. It is therefore important that remaining early stones are properly identified, not only for their own archaeological significance, but also to protect the remains they identify.